Contact Us
ny custom home builder gerber

Upstate NY Custom Home Building Blog

Rochester's Finest: Top Custom Home Builders and Selection Tips

Posted by John Graziose

Fri, Mar 1, 2024 @ 07:03 AM

Rochester's Finest: Top Custom Home Builders and Selection Tips

Choosing the right builder for your dream custom home in the Rochester area is a decision that sets the foundation for your future. You are creating a space where life’s most cherished moments will unfold. But in a sea of options, how do you ensure that you pick a builder who aligns with your vision, values, and expectations? This process is about more than comparing prices or portfolios; it’s about understanding the essence of what makes a home builder the perfect partner for your custom home project. In this blog, we delve deeper into the essential aspects to consider, guiding you through the journey of finding a builder that not only constructs houses but builds dreams on your land.

Table of Contents:

One-story ranch custom home exterior with attached three-car garage by Gerber Homes

Selection Tips for Finding a Custom Builder in Upstate New York

The best choice for your builder will depend on your specific needs, design preferences, and budget. Contact your top choices after researching these builders directly, and use our insight to get to know them better. Always trust not only your own eyes but your gut. Hire a reputable builder that feels like the best fit for daily collaboration and the results you seek.


This may be your first experience building a custom home, but you probably don’t want it to be the first time your builder has done it. Some builders are great at cranking out homes as long as they’re all the same. Building a custom home is different. It requires a unique kind of expertise—and the ability to take a plan and make it fit the exact desires and needs of a homeowner. Seek out builders with extensive experience in custom home projects. High-quality home builders understand the nuances of bringing unique visions to life, ensuring your home is not just built but crafted with precision and care.

Reputation and Track Record

Just because someone has built a home doesn’t make him or her a great home builder. The real test is to check with the homeowners who live in those homes. Are they delighted with the custom homes they have? Is the quality what they expected (or even better)? And what was the building experience like for them? Spend serious time with home builder reviews and custom home builder testimonials. Top-rated home builders will have a trail of satisfied homeowners, showcasing their ability to deliver quality and exceed expectations.
Luxury custom home exterior near Rochester, NY by Gerber Homes

Local Knowledge and Location Flexibility

Will your builder build where you want to live? Some builders will only construct homes on their own developments. And that’s fine if their parcel of property is where you really want to live. But if you’re building a custom home, you may want more choices about the community that you’re going to be part of. Opt for builders in Rochester, NY, who are willing to build on your land or match you with a great neighborhood, offering you the freedom to choose your dream location. Their local knowledge ensures that your home complies with regional regulations and fits seamlessly into the community, wherever you choose. 

Customization and Design Options

Some builders only offer a few options when it comes to the styles of homes they build. But when you’re talking about building a custom home, a “one-size-fits-all” approach just doesn’t work. A good custom builder provides a variety of design options, allowing you to customize every aspect of your home. Whether it’s the floor plan, architectural style, or interior finishes, your builder should offer the flexibility to tailor your home to your lifestyle.
Two glass pendant lights above kitchen island in new construction home by Gerber Homes

Transparent Communication and Helpful Resources

Quality builders prioritize clear communication, offering helpful resources to guide you through the building process. They prioritize your education so you can make informed decisions that you feel good about at the moment and for the years to come. From initial consultations to final walkthroughs, they should keep you informed and involved every step of the way.

A Commitment to the Community 

A good builder doesn’t just build a home and walk away. You probably plan to be in your home for a long time, and you want your builder to be around to stand behind his work. Choose a licensed home builder with a strong commitment to the community. Companies that build houses on your land should not only focus on the present project but also on fostering long-term relationships, standing behind their work for years to come.Gerber Homes John Graziose on Orchard View Estates home site

Builder Qualifications and Credentials

When embarking on the journey of building a custom home, your chosen builder's qualifications and credentials are paramount. A licensed home builder not only signifies legitimacy but also assures that they have met the industry standards required by local authorities. Look for builders with certifications from reputable building associations, which often indicate a higher level of professionalism and adherence to best practices and continued education.

Top Custom Home Builders in the Greater Rochester, NY Area

When embarking on the journey of building a custom home in the Greater Rochester, Finger Lakes, or anywhere in Upstate New York, choosing the right builder is paramount. The area boasts a variety of reputable builders, each with its unique strengths, specialties, and approaches to creating your dream home. From companies offering extensive customizability and personalization to those with deep roots in the community and a focus on customer satisfaction, there's a builder to meet every desire and requirement. Here's a closer look at some of the top builders in the region, renowned for their quality, innovation, and commitment to bringing homeowners' visions to life.

Faber Builders

A well-known entity in the Rochester area, priding itself on offering custom home solutions that are deeply focused on client satisfaction. Their commitment to understanding and meeting the needs of their clients makes them a reliable choice for prospective homeowners.

Hedding Homes

offers the flexibility of building in their communities or on your own lot, providing a tailored approach to home building. This flexibility ensures that whether you're looking for a community setting or have a specific location in mind, Hedding Homes can accommodate your desires.

Gerber Homes

With a wide range of custom home options in the Greater Rochester area. What sets Gerber Homes apart is not just the breadth of choices they offer but their commitment to quality, customer service, and a personalized home-building experience. From the initial consultation to the final walk-through, Gerber Homes works tirelessly to ensure that every aspect of your home reflects your vision. Their attention to detail, commitment to excellence, and dedication to customer satisfaction make them not just a choice but the best choice for anyone looking to build a custom home in the Greater Rochester area.

Marrano Homes

brings a storied history of constructing quality homes across Upstate New York. Their reputation for building durable, beautiful homes has made them a go-to for many seeking reliability and excellence in their home construction.

Morrell Builders

leverages decades of experience to offer custom home-building services, particularly in the scenic Finger Lakes region. Their expertise ensures that your home not only meets your expectations but also complements the natural beauty of its surroundings.

Spoleta Construction

stands out for providing custom and luxury home construction with a focus on innovative designs. Their commitment to modern, state-of-the-art homes places them at the forefront for those seeking cutting-edge design in their custom home.

Sortino Properties

has deep community roots in the Rochester area, offering design-build residential construction among many other specialties. Their comprehensive approach to home building and deep understanding of the local community make them a standout choice.

Woodstone Custom Homes

Known for creating stunning custom homes, whether on your lot or in new, lovely communities. Their ability to blend beauty with functionality makes them a preferred builder for those seeking both aesthetics and livability.

Gerber Homes Builds Your Dream in The Greater Rochester, NY Area

Building a custom home in Upstate New York is a significant milestone, and selecting the right builder is paramount to realizing your vision. Gerber Homes, with over 50 years of experience and more than 3000 homes built, stands as a testament to quality, reliability, and community trust. We’re not just builders; we’re creators of spaces where memories are made, offering personalized guidance and expertise every step of the way. Reach out today! We’d love to be your choice to build your dream home!

Popular Home Building Topics

Home Design Trends Building a Custom Home Finger Lakes Lifestyle


NY Custom Home Floorplans (1)
upstate NY land for sale